New China Mobile Chief Sends Bad Signals 中国移动新任领导传递糟糕迹象

By newsdoug on April 18, 2012

China Mobile (HKEx: 941; NYSE: CHL) marked a major milestone last month when Wang Jianzhou stepped down as its long-serving chairman, leaving a mixed legacy at the world’s largest mobile carrier that included the start of what could easily become a long-term decline. Now it is up to the company’s new leaders to try to halt that downward trend, or risk seeing a company that pioneered mobile service in China slowly slide into the realm of second-tier player. One of the first major signals from the company’s new leaders since Wang’s departure a month ago wasn’t very encouraging. That sign came at a recent press conference, where new Chairman Xi Guohua said China Mobile would launch a commercial fourth-generation network in the tech-savvy former British colony by year-end that could support its own homegrown 4G technology standard, called TD-LTE. That announcement — Xi’s first as chairman — continued Wang’s legacy of strongly promoting 4G as the answer to his company’s sputtering fortunes, even though China’s telecoms regulator has indicated it won’t issue commercial 4G licenses for at least a couple of years – the equivalent of an eternity for a fast-moving business like mobile service. Instead of fixating on 4G, Xi and his new leadership team need to turn their focus to China Mobile’s neglected 3G network, based on another homegrown standard called TD-SCDMA. Despite spending billions of dollars to build a TD-SCDMA network, which is already technologically inferior to products from its rivals, China Mobile has done little to promote or develop its 3G service and is rapidly losing position in the space as a result. In his 8 years at China Mobile, Wang built the company into one of the world’s most profitable and cash-rich mobile carriers, increasing its share to a dominant 72 percent of the market by late 2008 from 65 percent when he arrived. But then he hit a roadblock in early 2009 when China formally awarded licenses for 3G. Unlike rivals China Unicom (HKEx: 762; NYSE: CHU) and China Telecom (HKEx: 728; NYSE: CHA), whose licenses allowed them to build networks based on globally developed technologies, China Mobile was ordered to build its network using the homegrown and problem-plagued TD-SCDMA standard. Rather than use China Mobile’s huge cash pile and dominant market position to aggressively develop 3G, the company under Wang spent billions of dollars to build a patchy 3G network and did little to attract new subscribers. It then proceeded to tell the market it was placing its bets on next-generation 4G technology that looked like it wouldn’t be ready for commercial service for at least 2 to 3 years. As the company did this, its share of the 3G market rapidly deteriorated, from around 45 percent a year ago to a current 39 percent. The recent Hong Kong initiative seems to signal 4G will remain the company’s main focus under Xi’s new leadership, continuing Wang’s policy. The only problem is, if the current trends continue, China Mobile could easily see its share of the 3G market – whose users will be the first to make the switch to 4G – rapidly erode to the point where it falls to second or even third place by the time 4G licenses are awarded. By then, China Mobile could well discover that many of its former subscribers who defected to its rivals’ better 3G networks are happy where they are, meaning it will be too late to win them back to the 4G network that is now receiving so much of its energy and resources.

Bottom line: China Mobile’s new leaders need to end the company’s fixation on 4G and focus on the present or risk seeing their company become a second-tier player.

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)