Yum’s New Tie-Up Smells of Slowdown 百胜在苏宁店内开餐厅

By newsdoug on May 11, 2012

I was initially intrigued on reading that restaurant operator Yum (NYSE: YUM) was forging a new tie-up to open its KFC and Pizza Hut restaurants in appliance stores owned by Suning (Shenzhen: 002024), one of China’s top retailers, in what seems like a good expansion opportunity. (English article) But after some more consideration, this kind of a move almost looks to me more like a sign that Yum, after years of relentless expansion in China, may finally be running out of good growth opportunities in the huge market and is now having to look for newer, less obvious areas for expansion. If that’s the case, look for Yum’s phenomenal China growth to slow markedly in the next couple of years, putting a big damper on one of its few big growth stories that has made the company a popular investment choice even as many of its other major global markets remain sluggish. Let’s look at the actual news, which has Yum planning to open 150 new restaurants under its KFC, Pizza Hut and newly acquired Little Sheep hot pot brands in Suning stores over the next 5 years. This latest announcement comes as Yum now has 5,000 restaurants in China, with plans to open another 600 in the near future, further consolidating its spot as the country’s biggest operator ahead of the second largest player, McDonalds (NYSE: MCD), which has about 1,500 stores now and is aiming for 2,000 by the end of next year. Yum’s Suning tie-up looks similar in its less conventional nature to McDonalds plan announced last year to build up its drive-through business catering to a growing number of Chinese car owners. (previous post) That plan was followed by news in November that Yum itself was forging its own new partnership with oil major Sinopec (HKEx: 386; NYSE: SNP; Shanghai: 600028) to open restaurants in gas stations. (previous post) McDonalds is also exploring greatly expanding its franchising business, similar to what it already does in the US. While I applaud all these new moves for their innovation, they also seem to reflect the increasingly apparent reality that China’s first- and second-tier cities where Yum has found most of its success so far are quickly becoming saturated, with fewer and fewer attractive new opportunities for expansion. Gas stations and now Suning appliance stores certainly get lots of traffic, but it’s far from clear to me that either of these new initiatives will provide a big new growth area, as people who go to these places don’t usually come to eat a meal, though perhaps they might enjoy a snack during their visit. All that said, I would expect many of these new initiatives, including this new Suning tie-up, to produce very mixed results, contrasting sharply with the stellar performance of most of Yum’s existing China stores. If that’s the case, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Yum’s China growth slow quite a bit in the next 2 years, which seems almost inevitable, and for many of these new initiatives to ultimately end up as only modest successes or perhaps even as failures.

Bottom line: Yum’s latest tie-up with Suning appliance stores is the latest in a growing number of unusual new initiatives that show it may be reaching the saturation point in China.

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)